It’s time to call ESPN’s Adam Rittenberg to the table. He gets away with far too many unsupported statements. His latest: “We can debate whether Ohio State’s Sugar Bowl win is tainted by the suspension drama, but the Buckeyes showed that at full strength, they’re one of the nation’s best teams.”
The evidence against his claim:
1 – Ohio State had a total of 93 yards of offense in the second half. While everyone seems to be making a big deal of Pryor’s 336 total yards, he was a no show in the second half. Apparently, Rittenberg chose to ignore this when he wrote, “Terrelle Pryor is a big-time bowl performer.” What?! Are you kidding me? Terrelle Pryor couldn’t complete a third down pass in the third quarter. What did his coach do in the fourth quarter? Having lost complete confidence in this big-time bowl performer,” Tressel didn’t allow Pryor to attempt another third down pass in the fourth quarter. Even when faced with a third and 15, he had Pryor attempt to run for a first down, and the big time bowl performer came up a yard short. Tressel basically told Pryor and anyone watching that he didn’t have confidence in his quarterback. This message seems to be quite the contrary to “you’re a big time bowl performer, Terrelle.”
2 – Faced with a fourth and one, Tressel elected to go for it, and one of the nation’s best teams fumbled the ball and failed to pick up a first down to ice the game. Please note that Tressel had Pryor hand off the ball to Saine. Why didn’t Pryor run the ball himself if he was such a big time bowl performer? Perhaps the memory of Pryor fumbling against Penn State on fourth and one still flashed in the mind of Tressel. If you are truly a big time bowl performer, the coach gives you the ball in that situation.
3 – With a little over a minute to go in the game, Ohio State punted from their own 38 yard line. One of the nation’s best teams (despite their troubles all year long with special teams) had the punt blocked. Arkansas, however, didn’t have the sense to scoop up the ball and run it the remaining 18 yards into the end zone. How can you be one of the nation’s best teams if you’ve had trouble all year with special teams?
4 – Pryor was a measly 1 for 6 in the second half against Arkansas. That’s a whopping 16% completion rate folks. He would have been worse but his coach had the good sense to take the ball out of his hands in the fourth quarter.
Conclusion – I’m not sure how Pryor won the MVP for the Sugar Bowl when he only showed up for half the game. If anything the award should have gone to Cam Heyward who played at a high level throughout the entire (i.e., whole) game. Without Heyward, OSU would have been rocked by Arkansas. Ohio State may have one of the nation’s best defenses but they only played one half of offense and special teams are a major issue. Not sure how you can be one of the nation’s best teams when your offense doesn’t show up for half the game and special teams are a significant liability.
Back up your statements, Rittenberg. I’m calling you to the table from now on.